A few days ago, I went for a movie. It must be at least two years since I last went out for a film.
It was for Aamir Khan’s Sitaare Zameen Par (Stars on Earth).
Though this film is similar to his own 2007 film Taare Zameen Par (Stars on Earth), the story is very different. This is an official remake of 2018 Spanish movie Champions.
The central theme is: differently abled people are no less intelligent or less smart than any one of us. In fact, the so-called “normal” people have a lot to learn from the so-called “disabled”.
Gulshan, played by Aamir Khan, is a school basketball coach. He is very good at his game but not as a person. He is full of ego, short-tempered, doesn't know how to get on with people, etc.
He gets into trouble during a tournament and the case reaches the court which asks him to do community service in lieu of a jail term.
His job: train a basketball team of young adults who are intellectually challenged.
At first, he doesn’t take it seriously, but slowly, the team changes his perspective.
And he is reformed.
In the end at one point he says: "I am not their coach, they are my coach."
One message from the film was "Everyone has their own kind of normal".
This is a sensitive topic, and Aamir Khan has handled it very well.
Though there a fair amount of comedy thrown in, characters' personalities are shown with the seriousness and respect they deserve. They are at no point shown as helpless.
In real life too
It's not the theme alone that makes this movie purposeful, it's also the fact that many of the actors live with disabilities in real life.
For example, Gopi Krishnan Varma, who plays the role of 'Guddu', has Down Syndrome. He has previously acted in a Malayalam movie, Thirike (2021).
So too, is Simran Mangeshkar who plays the role of 'Golu'.
Samvit Desai, who is 'Kareem' in the movie, is neurodivergent. Rishi Sahani and Ayush Bansali too are intellectually challenged.
Genelia Deshmukh plays the role of Aamir's wife Sunita, and comes across well in the limited screen time she gets.
What the film seemed to lack
On the downside, I thought the transformation of Gulshan, the coach, didn't come across as powerfully as it should have. There were several points to it, but it didn't look like he was a changed person.
Also, as the movie progressed, many of the sequences in the initial stages seemed predictable, and I seriously wondered where was the story heading to, and how it would end.
But, I must say, the ending was good, and it packed and delivered the social message quite well.
I’d give a rating of 4 out of 5.
Overall, a simple, emotional story with an important social message told with warmth and respect.
I watched Taare... bacl then and loved it. This must be good too, given Khan's dedication to his job.
ReplyDeleteHi Tomi - I am sure you will like this.
DeleteHari Om
ReplyDeleteI'm a huge AK fan, so must see if I can get this online... Amazon is quite good at showing Indian cinema! YAM xx
I too am an Aamir Khan fan. Not quite sure if this is on OTT right now, considering it was released only on movie halls in India just last month.
DeleteProbably, outside India, it might be on OTT. Yes, definitely worth checking out.
If it's not there now, I am sure it'll come before long.
Thanks for the wonderful review. I always liked Genelia as an actress.
ReplyDeleteI hadn't watched any of her films. Here she had a limited role. I think I should watch some of her movies.
DeleteI can't remember the last time I went to see a movie, I rarely even watch them at home
ReplyDeleteI can understand. I have friends here who don't watch films, at home or outside.
DeleteWhile working all these years, movies were very low down on my priority list, unless a film was making news.
But now that I am retired, I think I must explore some good ones out there.
They remade that film in the US as well. I saw it streaming someplace. It's a great theme, and it's best when they cast actors with developmental disabilities to play the parts. Because there are actors like that, and they know their business.
ReplyDeleteI saw a few clippings of an English movie in the same theme. I'll try to catch up with this movie in OTT sometime :)
ReplyDeleteDestination Infinity
Hi Rajesh - I am sure it will come on OTT soon, if it hasn't aleady.
DeleteI watched this movie, and would never miss because its Amir khan, watched a lot of his movies, like Dangal, Lagaan, Tare Zameen par, PK, 3 idiots... enjoyed all of them, and he was the perfect cast. I am glad to go to the theater and watched with my daughter. I could relate to this movie well as I had a son who was down syndrome and lived only for 7 years... can never forget him and all that i learnt from him as his mom, my daughter got emotional... probably thinking of her brother. I was happy to see this movie and it was worth my time. Thanks for sharing:)
ReplyDeleteI came here second time to comment:) as the previous comment was not to be seen. Just wanted to say that I loved this movie, watched with my daughter in the theater. I love watching Amir khans movies - like dangal, lagaan, PK, 3 idiots, tare zameen par and other entertaining ones too. This was relatable as i had a down syndrome son who lived only for 7 years, but left a lasting impression on my life, my daughter got teary as she watched and i could understand... He was a blessing in our family. Thanks for sharing this post.
ReplyDeleteFor older posts, I have enabled comment moderation, in order to minimise spam. That's why your comment didn't appear, since I have to approve it. Apologies for the inconvenience. Maybe I will remove the comment moderation, because it's not that I receive a lot of spam comments.
DeleteI am moved by how your family connected with the movie, especially given your son's beautiful presence in your lives. I am also humbled that the blog post led to heartfelt recollections.
The fact that this movie is being watched and liked by so many people, just goes to show how people relate to the theme. His earlier film Taare Zameen Par was also received very well. The movies have also brought in a lot of changes in the way such situations are handled and appreciated.
Good wishes to you and your daughter and thank you for reading the post and for the heartwarming comment.